When you think of a luxurious Caribbean getaway, St. Barts and Anguilla likely come to mind. Both islands offer beautiful beaches, clear waters, and a unique charm. However, they are not the same. Each island has its own character, and what is perfect depends on the type of vacation you want.
St. Barts: where French chic meets island charm
St. Barts is a small piece of the French Riviera in the Caribbean. Celebrities often dock their yachts here, enjoying a blend of elegance and Caribbean charm. The island is small, covering only 9 square miles. It has dramatic cliffs and hidden coves. You can also find a mix of lively and calm beaches. The French influence is clear, from the language to the high-quality dining that still feels relaxed. It’s the kind of place where you can sip rosé at a beach club one moment and snorkel in a hidden cove the next.
The vibe? Understated luxury. St. Barts is chic without being flashy. Think beachy sophistication where high-end style and barefoot relaxation coexist.
Anguilla: peace, privacy, and powdery beaches
Anguilla, on the other hand, is all about quiet elegance. This British territory has a more chilled-out feel, with unspoiled beaches and a pace of life that encourages you to slow down. At 35 square miles, it’s bigger than St. Barts but flat, with some of the most breathtaking beaches in the world.
What sets Anguilla apart is its Afro-Caribbean culture—there’s reggae in the air, fresh seafood on your plate, and a genuine warmth that makes you feel instantly at home. The dining scene is less formal than St. Barts, but the flavors? Just as memorable.
The vibe? Pure serenity. Anguilla isn’t about being seen—it’s about being. It’s the perfect place to unplug, unwind, and let the rhythm of the island carry you.
Beaches: glam vs. bliss
- St. Barts: You’ve got variety here. St-Jean Beach buzzes with energy, water sports, and chic crowds, while Colombier and Saline are all about peaceful vibes and untouched beauty.
- Anguilla: The beaches are next-level stunning—soft white sand and clear, calm water everywhere you turn. Shoal Bay East is a fan favorite, but spots like Meads Bay and Rendezvous Bay are just as dreamy.
Dining and nightlife: haute cuisine or local flavor?
- St. Barts: This is foodie heaven. French gastronomy takes center stage, with standout spots like Bonito and L’Esprit. Nightlife is lively too, with places like Le Ti St. Barth offering late-night fun and dancing.
- Anguilla: Think more relaxed but equally delicious. Beachside spots like Blanchards serve fresh, flavorful meals, and live music often replaces the club scene. It’s all about good vibes, not late-night partying.
Accommodations: private villas or intimate resorts?
- St. Barts: Known for its stunning villas, many with ocean views, infinity pools, and concierge services. Boutique hotels like Eden Rock add another layer of luxury, but private stays steal the show.
- Anguilla: There’s a mix of boutique resorts like Cap Juluca and private villas that blend luxury with intimacy. Privacy and comfort are the priorities here.
The decision: chic buzz or quiet bliss?
Choose St. Barts if you’re in the mood for a glamorous, cosmopolitan vibe—designer shopping, upscale dining, and maybe a little yacht-spotting. It’s perfect if you love being in the middle of the action (with a glass of champagne in hand).
Choose Anguilla if you want to escape the hustle and focus on natural beauty, peace, and relaxation. It’s the ideal spot for couples or anyone looking for a slower, more personal island experience.
The truth is, you can’t go wrong with either. Whether you’re clinking glasses at a chic beach club or walking barefoot on a deserted beach, both islands are pure paradise. The only real question is: what kind of paradise are you in the mood for?
